Thursday, September 29, 2005
The Trinity - It's a Big Deal
I have a pet peeve. It's a heresy that drives me absolutely nuts. It's called
Modalism
"In Christianity, Sabellianism (also known as modalism) is the second century belief that the three persons of the Trinity are merely different modes or aspects of God, rather than three distinct persons. It is attributed to Sabellius, who taught a form of this doctrine in Rome in the second century. Hippolytus knew Sabellius personally and mentions him in the Philosophumena. He knows Sabellius disliked Trinitarian theology, but he calls Modal Monarchism the heresy of Noetos, not that of Sabellius. Hippolytus thought he had very nearly recounciled Sabellius to the mainstream church. However, during the controversy surrounding Paul of Samosata, the Patriarch of Antioch who was deposed in 268 for his Christology, Sabellius' name was mentioned. No one in Antioch had heard of him, but his name was associated with Rome. So they wrote to Rome about him. Pope Dionysius replied in a letter of which only a small fragment has been preserved, but this letter was enough to make Sabellius famous among the Greek theologians.
Sabellianism was also embraced by Christians in Cyrenaica, to whom Demetrius, Patriarch of Alexandria, wrote letters arguing against this belief.
Another name for this doctrine is Patripassianism from the Latin words patris for "father", and passus for "to suffer". This name was given because the doctrine implies that God the Father came to earth and suffered in the form of God the Son.
Today, Sabellianism is rejected by most types of Christianity. It is accepted primarily by some Pentecostal groups, sometimes referred to as Oneness Pentecostals or "Jesus Only" Pentecostals.
Historic Sabellianism taught that God the Father was the only person of the Godhead, but the Oneness doctrine of today says that this one member of the Godhead is Jesus. Oneness doctrine claims that when Scripture describes the Father or the Holy_Spirit, it is actually Jesus, who is only revealing Himself as one of the other modes of God. Some Oneness followers call this the "Jesus Only doctrine".
taken from:
http://www.knowledgerush.com/kr/encyclopedia/Modalism"
Well, the reason it's a big deal to me (and a few others) is that it is a distortion of the Truth. Not just my truth, but Truth as revealed to us thru the Scriptures and as interpreted by those I'd consider Orthodox (not necessarily eastern in this sense of the word)
but Orthodox as in holding to Truth as believed by all Christians everywhere at all times. And the Trinity is really a beautiful concept. Cause we show that the Father is the Eternal Father. If God has eternally been the Father then it just naturally follows that the Son has eternally been the Son... And the Holy Spirit has been there as the Spirit that brings it all together (sigh words are so inadequate)...
Cause you can't be a Father without a Child. So in the Trinity we glimpse a picture of a trio of beings who are in love withone another, perfect love from before Time began.
The other reason it's such a big deal is because in those distortions of truth, what we commonly call heresy, cults are born. Cults are breeding grounds for legalism and Toxic Religion which looks like it's there to help you, but just hurts you even more and more.
Modalism
"In Christianity, Sabellianism (also known as modalism) is the second century belief that the three persons of the Trinity are merely different modes or aspects of God, rather than three distinct persons. It is attributed to Sabellius, who taught a form of this doctrine in Rome in the second century. Hippolytus knew Sabellius personally and mentions him in the Philosophumena. He knows Sabellius disliked Trinitarian theology, but he calls Modal Monarchism the heresy of Noetos, not that of Sabellius. Hippolytus thought he had very nearly recounciled Sabellius to the mainstream church. However, during the controversy surrounding Paul of Samosata, the Patriarch of Antioch who was deposed in 268 for his Christology, Sabellius' name was mentioned. No one in Antioch had heard of him, but his name was associated with Rome. So they wrote to Rome about him. Pope Dionysius replied in a letter of which only a small fragment has been preserved, but this letter was enough to make Sabellius famous among the Greek theologians.
Sabellianism was also embraced by Christians in Cyrenaica, to whom Demetrius, Patriarch of Alexandria, wrote letters arguing against this belief.
Another name for this doctrine is Patripassianism from the Latin words patris for "father", and passus for "to suffer". This name was given because the doctrine implies that God the Father came to earth and suffered in the form of God the Son.
Today, Sabellianism is rejected by most types of Christianity. It is accepted primarily by some Pentecostal groups, sometimes referred to as Oneness Pentecostals or "Jesus Only" Pentecostals.
Historic Sabellianism taught that God the Father was the only person of the Godhead, but the Oneness doctrine of today says that this one member of the Godhead is Jesus. Oneness doctrine claims that when Scripture describes the Father or the Holy_Spirit, it is actually Jesus, who is only revealing Himself as one of the other modes of God. Some Oneness followers call this the "Jesus Only doctrine".
taken from:
http://www.knowledgerush.com/kr/encyclopedia/Modalism"
Well, the reason it's a big deal to me (and a few others) is that it is a distortion of the Truth. Not just my truth, but Truth as revealed to us thru the Scriptures and as interpreted by those I'd consider Orthodox (not necessarily eastern in this sense of the word)
but Orthodox as in holding to Truth as believed by all Christians everywhere at all times. And the Trinity is really a beautiful concept. Cause we show that the Father is the Eternal Father. If God has eternally been the Father then it just naturally follows that the Son has eternally been the Son... And the Holy Spirit has been there as the Spirit that brings it all together (sigh words are so inadequate)...
Cause you can't be a Father without a Child. So in the Trinity we glimpse a picture of a trio of beings who are in love withone another, perfect love from before Time began.
The other reason it's such a big deal is because in those distortions of truth, what we commonly call heresy, cults are born. Cults are breeding grounds for legalism and Toxic Religion which looks like it's there to help you, but just hurts you even more and more.
